logo new
Login as: Member Non-Member
2 minutes reading time (327 words)

South Carolina U.S. District Court issues nationwide injunction rendering CWR Suspension Rule void

nature-3554573_1280

The U.S. District Court for the District of South Carolina found that the Trump administration improperly suspended the Clean Water Rule (Read the Order).


Specifically, the Court held that (1) the EPA and Corps violated the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) by refusing to solicit public comment on the merits of suspending the Clean Water Rule and (2) the EPA and the Corps violated the APA in refusing to consider the substantive implications of suspending the Clean Water Rule.

The District Court has issued a nationwide injunction, effectively rendering the Suspension Rule void. (See footnote 4 for the Court's reasoning for the nationwide injunction.)

What does this mean for the Clean Water Rule?
The short answer is that it appears that the Clean Water Rule will apply in up to 26 States. This decision is likely to be appealed by the government and industry groups (both on the merits and regarding the scope of the injunction).

With respect to the remainder of the States, the rules in place prior to the Clean Water Rule still apply. The decision in South Carolina only dealt with the process surrounding the Suspension Rule. In other litigation, various District Courts (including the U.S. District Court for the District of North Dakota) have enjoined the Clean Water Rule based on a substantive challenge. These cases continue.

What does this mean for the SDNY and ND litigation in which SWS is amicus?
The case in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York is a procedural challenge to the Suspension Rule, on the same grounds as in the South Carolina case. The States challenging the Suspension Rule have already notified the Court about the South Carolina decision.

The case in the U.S. District Court for the District of North Dakota is a substantive challenge to the Clean Water Rule. Now that the Suspension Rule is enjoined, it makes it more likely that the Court will proceed to make a decision on the merits.

Another Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Clean Wa...

Related Posts

 

Comments 7

adv ydv on Tuesday, 11 September 2018 18:31

hello everyone, I want to tell you all that if you have a problem connecting your PC to the wireless system, fix connections to bluetooth audio device and wirelesses displays in window 10 then first of all you have to learn about this step on this platform to do this.

hello everyone, I want to tell you all that if you have a problem connecting your PC to the wireless system, [url=http://windowstuts.net/connections] fix connections to bluetooth audio device and wirelesses displays in window 10[/url] then first of all you have to learn about this step on this platform to do this.
nataliajohnson on Saturday, 22 September 2018 10:50

I prefer being right here in the Raleigh area. The people are friendly. The city is big enough that there's plenty to do but not so big that you spend all your time sitting in traffic. I'm completely unimpressed with my youngest brother's experiences in South Carolina public schools and colleges. Assignment expert writing service

I prefer being right here in the Raleigh area. The people are friendly. The city is big enough that there's plenty to do but not so big that you spend all your time sitting in traffic. I'm completely unimpressed with my youngest brother's experiences in South Carolina public schools and colleges. [url=https://www.assignmentland.co.uk]Assignment expert writing service[/url]
Antonia Cummins on Tuesday, 25 September 2018 12:38

Just landed a position as a visit manage at an untamed life asylum and professional flowerbed. It pays the lowest pay permitted by law and I need to keep my retail employment to remain above water, yet there are flamingos. AT WORK Custom Essay Help Service. There are stream otters, mountain bears, pumas, and catamounts. AT WORK. I get the chance to see owls consistently. I get the opportunity to drive a cable car and discuss plants and nobody feigns exacerbation or attempts to change the subject. I need to live once more. I'm going to be alright.

Just landed a position as a visit manage at an untamed life asylum and professional flowerbed. It pays the lowest pay permitted by law and I need to keep my retail employment to remain above water, yet there are flamingos. AT WORK [url=https://www.freshessays.co.uk/]Custom Essay Help Service[/url]. There are stream otters, mountain bears, pumas, and catamounts. AT WORK. I get the chance to see owls consistently. I get the opportunity to drive a cable car and discuss plants and nobody feigns exacerbation or attempts to change the subject. I need to live once more. I'm going to be alright.
Jacob Arch on Thursday, 04 October 2018 10:17

Objective landed a post as a visitor to manage in a not tamed life shelter and professional flower bed. It pays the minimum wage allowed by law and write my assignment for me, I need to keep my retail employment in the water, but there are flamingos. No. I have the opportunity to see owls often. I had the opportunity to drive the cable car and discuss the plants, no one pretending to deteriorate or trying to change the subject. I need to live again. I will be fine.

Objective landed a post as a visitor to manage in a not tamed life shelter and professional flower bed. It pays the minimum wage allowed by law and [url=https://www.assignmentsquare.co.uk/]write my assignment for me[/url], I need to keep my retail employment in the water, but there are flamingos. No. I have the opportunity to see owls often. I had the opportunity to drive the cable car and discuss the plants, no one pretending to deteriorate or trying to change the subject. I need to live again. I will be fine.
Abdul on Wednesday, 10 October 2018 11:05

I think not a good decision from the side of administration that suspended the Clean Water Rule. They should take the positive step who is good for everyone. Sometimes these types of things create lots of problems that are not for our enviroment. well, taking the more guidance about suspension rule wide you can also use our professional research paper writer UAE.

I think not a good decision from the side of administration that suspended the Clean Water Rule. They should take the positive step who is good for everyone. Sometimes these types of things create lots of problems that are not for our enviroment. well, taking the more guidance about suspension rule wide you can also use our professional [url=https://www.assignmenthelp.ae/research-paper-writing-service.php]research paper writer[/url] UAE.
Alex Walden on Monday, 03 December 2018 09:03

Simple Gmail sign up new account in 2018

Simple [url=https://www.just4dummies.com/gmail-sign-up]Gmail sign up[/url] new account in 2018
Michael Robert on Friday, 07 December 2018 11:17

Clean water is necessary for all human I saw in news many countries and it states didn’t have proper water and also their use the dirty water animals and humans water are same in that states I think it is most essential need of every human I am planning to write assignment writing services online to the topic of clean water for all humanity in all the states of every country.

Clean water is necessary for all human I saw in news many countries and it states didn’t have proper water and also their use the dirty water animals and humans water are same in that states I think it is most essential need of every human I am planning to write [url=https://www.assignmenttutor.co.uk/]assignment writing services online[/url] to the topic of clean water for all humanity in all the states of every country.
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Wednesday, 12 December 2018
If you'd like to register, please fill in the username, password and name fields.